Last week I made the point that real readers are becoming frighteningly uncommon, so in an effort to get people to read more, I thought I’d share with the world why I love some of the hot and hated books right now – and, therefore, why I think they’re worth reading. Last week’s post was about Stephanie Meyer and her books, the Twilight Saga and The Host (click here to read last week’s post!), and this week’s topic is going to be about Christopher Paolini and his books, the Inheritance Cycle (a.k.a. the Eragon books)!
Now I know this one might not be hated as hotly as the Twilight books are, but (in my experience, at least), I’ve gotten a lot of sneers for confessing my love for these books (and I know a lot of friends who have gotten sneers for liking them, too). Some of the arguments I’ve heard most often against Paolini’s books (there are four: Eragon, Eldest, Brisingr, and Inheritance) are that he uses too much description, the language he uses is hard to understand, his characters/the setting/the world/the storyline are not believable, etc., etc. There are many more things I’ve heard people say about how “bad” these books are, but the ones I listed are what I’m going to address, so I’ll stop there.
For one thing, I thing it’s pointless to argue that a book’s plot or characters or setting is unbelievable – especially when that book is clearly fiction. The whole point of setting a novel in another world is so that your readers aren’t always worrying about whether something in the story is “believable” or not. And I’m making this argument as both a reader/book-lover AND writer/aspiring-novelist. So don’t call something in a fiction book “unbelievable” unless you know that the author intended the story to be accurate to life… or unless you mean it in the “this book is so awesome!!” sense.
Description has always been a matter of opinion to me – some people like to read longer descriptions that paint pictures in the reader’s mind, and some people like less description so that they can let their imaginations fill in the details that were left out. It’s the difference between describing (for example) someone’s eyes as “the green-blue color of the ocean, shaded by thick, dark lashes” or simply as “piercing.” So in the case of Eragon and Paolini’s other books, I would agree that he has a lot of description – but I would also argue that his description is eloquent, beautiful and appropriate. He’s not another Melville. (If you don’t get that reference, go read Moby-Dick… or at least try.)
Which leads me to my next point – there’s nothing wrong with good, well-educated and well-used diction and vocabulary. Yes, I do think Paolini uses a lot of vocabulary that the average public high-schooler might not know, but so what? When you don’t know a word, look it up! (It’s called “LEARNING!”) I grew up reading tons of books that were technically “above” my reading level, so I learned a lot of words sooner than most other kids my age, and it actually gave me an advantage in my high school literature classes. Sure, you can call me a nerd if you want – or you can ask me what a word means and learn something yourself.
Ok, I can’t let this topic go until we talk about the film version of Eragon. Unfortunately, this is one instance where I agree with the general public (and in this case, the general public’s opinion is by far the majority opinion) – the movie was terrible. Bad acting, bad accuracy to the book (and I mean worse than usual, Hollywood), low budget, they never made the other books into movies (so we have no sense of how much better it could have been), and it just wasn’t very well made in general. Now don’t get me wrong – there are actors in there that I loved when they were in other films, but they just weren’t the right ones to play these characters… The books were epic and really well anticipated when they were still coming out, but I don’t think this movie was very highly anticipated – and of the people who did have high expectations, it turned out to be a sorry disappointment.
So those are my thoughts on Christopher Paolini and his Inheritance books! I’d be very interested to hear what your opinions are of these books, or, if you haven’t read any of them, whether my post has made you any more motivated to read them now! Thanks for reading, and have a great weekend!